Measuring CO2 Evolution at Bousson Environmental Research Reserve

Students taking samples

Figure 1 - Students gathering samples at Bousson Environmental Research Reserve.

data graph

data graph

To view close-up of graph, click on it.

There were three control and three fertilized plots 15 x 15 m. The fertilized plots received 100 kg N ha-1 yr-1 in the form of ammonium nitrate (NH4NO3). Amendments were made using a backpack sprayer covering the sample plot twice to ensure equal distribution. Four stratified sampling locations were selected in each fertilized and control plot for measuring CO2 efflux.

Carbon dioxide efflux measurements were taken using a soda-lime technique similar to Edwards (1982). Measurement chambers were 20 cm tall by 27.5 cm in diameter plastic buckets. Prior to measuring, plastic rings of the same diameter as the measurement chambers were placed over the soil. Surface litter found on the edge of the ring was moved and the ring was pushed ~1 cm into the soil. Carbon dioxide was absorbed by soil tins containing 60 g of 1.68- to 3.36-mm (6-12 mesh) indicator-grade soda-lime. Before use in the field, the tins of soda-lime were oven dried at 105°C for 24 hrs, weighed to the 0.0001 g, and covered with a lid. Field measurements were taken by removing the plastic ring from the soil and placing the uncovered tin in the center of the sample site. The measurement chamber was placed over the tins in the depression created by the ring. A weight was gently placed on the chamber to hold it in place. The soda lime was collected ~24 hours later, to include the diurnal cycle of respiration, oven dried at 105°C and reweighed.

During measurements six blanks were made. This was performed in an identical fashion as the CO2 measurements, with the exception of removing them from the chamber after 10-15 s. Blanks accounted for CO2 absorption during placement and retrieval of the tins, and during drying. Soil respiration was calculated as:

S = (Wsl x 1.69 x 0.2729)(Ac x T)

Where, S is CO2 evolution (mg C m-2 h-1), Wsl is the soda lime weight gain, 1.69 is the C absorption rate of soda-lime, 0.2729 is C/CO2, Ac is the chamber area (cm2), T is the sampling time in hours (Grogan, 1998).

Seventeen measurements of CO2 efflux were taken during 2002, from May until November when snow prohibited sampling. Sampling was done weekly during summer months May to July (at the height of CO2 evolution) and then bi-monthly afterwards. Changes in respiration at the fertilized plots were tested for significance using one-way Repeated Measures ANOVA of treatment means. Temperature and moisture measurements were taken at 2.5 cm below the soil surface, from May to September to correlate climatic variability with CO2 evolution. Moisture content was measured using time domain reflectometry (TDR) in % water filled pore space.

Soil respiration measurements at the control and fertilized plots at BERR from May to November using the Soda-Lime method
Date Treatment   CO2 Flux from bucket
(mg C m-2 h-1)
    Average
Flux
Average
Temperature
Average
Moisture
    A B C D   Celsius % water filled
pore space
30-May-02 Control 1 83 90 96 115 96 17 25
  Control 2 151 167 83 87 122 17 35
  Control 3 n.d. 43 56 57 52 16 31
  Fertilized 1 91 140 118 141 123 17 31
  Fertilized 2 92 101 86 76 89 17 26
  Fertilized 3 59 n.d. 70 77 69 17 31
6-Jun-02 Control 1 86 148 158 200 148 15 23
  Control 2 235 241 190 170 209 14 31
  Control 3 196 147 127 n.d. 156 15 29
  Fertilized 1 163 216 183 187 187 15 28
  Fertilized 2 211 197 202 183 198 15 27
  Fertilized 3 166 167 164 165 166 15 26
13-Jun-02 Control 1 197 198 220 204 205 17 21
  Control 2 247 321 223 256 262 17 29
  Control 3 241 168 226 162 199 17 27
  Fertilized 1 188 199 178 218 196 17 24
  Fertilized 2 198 182 174 165 180 17 22
  Fertilized 3 168 194 158 172 173 17 25
19-Jun-02 Control 1 183 166 208 192 187 16 19
  Control 2 227 n.d. 223 190 213 16 30
  Control 3 206 166 154 210 184 17 27
  Fertilized 1 170 197 195 192 189 16 21
  Fertilized 2 191 169 142 161 166 16 19
  Fertilized 3 187 205 189 173 188 17 24
27-Jun-02 Control 1 257 210 214 219 225 19 18
  Control 2 249 418 234 218 279 19 28
  Control 3 218 169 153 n.d. 180 18 22
  Fertilized 1 233 215 215 206 217 19 20
  Fertilized 2 221 198 185 201 201 19 16
  Fertilized 3 179 222 203 164 192 18 24
3-Jul-02 Control 1 203 200 200 219 206 21 12
  Control 2 224 n.d. 217 255 232 21 22
  Control 3 206 160 153 n.d. 173 20 20
  Fertilized 1 182 186 162 206 184 21 12
  Fertilized 2 217 183 185 192 194 21 12
  Fertilized 3 227 188 190 151 189 21 19
10-Jul-02 Control 1 183 181 219 235 205 17 14
  Control 2 253 n.d. 219 198 223 17 18
  Control 3 211 188 176 211 196 17 18
  Fertilized 1 225 222 184 203 209 17 13
  Fertilized 2 231 213 197 201 210 18 15
  Fertilized 3 196 193 212 170 193 18 18
16-Jul-02 Control 1 193 168 181 202 186 20 8
  Control 2 165 196 164 172 174 20 11
  Control 3 187 185 179 n.d. 184 19 13
  Fertilized 1 204 343 177 214 234 20 9
  Fertilized 2 187 184 n.d. 161 177 20 8
  Fertilized 3 180 181 170 133 166 19 11
22-Jul-02 Control 1 211 190 190 214 201 21 9
  Control 2 180 373 202 237 248 21 10
  Control 3 179 171 167 192 177 21 11
  Fertilized 1 180 189 179 212 190 46 13
  Fertilized 2 215 183 182 182 191 21 8
  Fertilized 3 185 192 198 167 185 21 10
29-Jul-02 Control 1 186 205 225 247 215 23 17
  Control 2 247 407 207 200 265 23 22
  Control 3 190 145 126 159 155 21 26
  Fertilized 1 198 233 193 232 214 23 22
  Fertilized 2 208 n.d. 201 201 204 23 18
  Fertilized 3 168 196 201 153 179 21 22
29-Aug-02 Control 1 209 120 162 175 166 n.d. n.d.
  Control 2 184 n.d. 159 189 177 n.d. n.d.
  Control 3 159 139 169 n.d. 156 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 1 149 147 148 148 148 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 2 186 150 137 146 155 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 3 131 170 151 158 153 n.d. n.d.
14-Sep-02 Control 1 140 116 n.d. 149 135 18 10
  Control 2 189 n.d. 105 151 148 18 14
  Control 3 n.d. 96 120 97 104 18 17
  Fertilized 1 118 n.d. 115 125 119 18 11
  Fertilized 2 105 142 110 n.d. 119 19 9
  Fertilized 3 104 140 115 n.d. 120 18 15
21-Sep-02 Control 1 225 175 223 283 226 n.d. n.d.
  Control 2 283 n.d. 223 n.d. 253 n.d. n.d.
  Control 3 212 166 203 n.d. 194 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 1 214 204 213 n.d. 210 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 2 196 275 219 267 239 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 3 265 268 254 206 248 n.d. n.d.
5-Oct-02 Control 1 196 n.d. 194 187 193 n.d. n.d.
  Control 2 n.d. n.d. 112 131 122 n.d. n.d.
  Control 3 148 110 130 111 125 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 1 135 n.d. 137 227 166 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 2 118 n.d. 109 154 127 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 3 n.d. 95 n.d. 131 113 n.d. n.d.
19-Oct-02 Control 1 199 160 n.d. 200 186 n.d. n.d.
  Control 2 n.d. 233 178 n.d. 206 n.d. n.d.
  Control 3 168 154 n.d. n.d. 161 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 1 202 183 n.d. 187 191 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 2 164 195 174 159 173 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 3 150 188 202 168 177 n.d. n.d.
9-Nov-02 Control 1 146 129 147 166 147 n.d. n.d.
  Control 2 147 181 n.d. 108 145 n.d. n.d.
  Control 3 155 126 164 160 151 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 1 155 n.d. n.d. 121 138 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 2 128 n.d. 127 125 127 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 3 127 151 152 149 145 n.d. n.d.
24-Nov-02 Control 1 76 n.d. 72 65 71 n.d. n.d.
  Control 2 52 88 64 50 63 n.d. n.d.
  Control 3 66 60 56 60 60 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 1 67 63 22 63 54 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 2 55 55 60 52 56 n.d. n.d.
  Fertilized 3 59 67 51 54 58 n.d. n.d.
                 
  n.d. = no data              
Download these data (Excel file)